From employment screening to safety evaluations, criminal background checks are crucial to the hiring process. It fuels better hiring decisions and makes recruiting futuristic and risk-proof.

In this guide, we take you through the world of criminal background checks, providing valuable insights into their purpose, significance, and practical implementation.

How do criminal background checks work?

Criminal background checks are a process that delves into an individual’s past, revealing crucial details that can impact their future opportunities. The process begins when an authorized entity requests a check, often through a specialized agency.

This agency then probes various databases, from local court records to national crime databases, seeking any hint of criminal activity. 

But it’s not just about finding a criminal record. It’s about understanding the context, the severity, and the relevance of any discovered offenses. 

It’s a complex, intricate process, but one that plays a pivotal role in maintaining safety and integrity in our society.

What makes criminal background checks important?

1. Safety first

Criminal background checks are paramount to ensuring safety. 

They help organizations mitigate risks by identifying individuals with a history of harmful behavior, thus creating a safer environment for everyone involved.

2. Trust and transparency

These checks foster trust and transparency. When an individual’s background aligns with their claims, it builds confidence in their integrity, promoting a culture of honesty and openness.

importance of criminal background check

3. Regulatory compliance

Many industries are legally required to conduct these checks. Non-compliance can lead to hefty fines, legal repercussions, and damage to the agency’s brand image.

4. Informed decisions

Background checks provide valuable insights that aid in making informed decisions, particularly in recruitment. 

They help employers assess candidates’ suitability based on past behavior and potential risks.

5. Protecting the company’s reputation 

At times employee actions can significantly impact a company’s reputation. 

Conducting background checks helps protect the company’s image and brand by ensuring they hire individuals who reflect their values.

6. Reducing negligent hiring risks

If an employee’s actions harm someone and it’s found that a thorough background check wasn’t conducted, companies can face negligent hiring lawsuits. 

Background checks help mitigate this risk.

7 types of criminal background checks 

1. County criminal record checks

These checks delve into county courthouse records where the individual resides or has resided. They’re crucial for uncovering local criminal activity.

2. Statewide criminal record checks

Through these checks, state law enforcement and court records are scanned. They’re useful for identifying crimes committed in the entire state.

3. Federal criminal record checks

They reveal crimes prosecuted at a federal level, such as fraud, embezzlement, or tax evasion. Quite essential for comprehensive background screening.

4. National criminal database checks

Using nationwide databases, these checks scan criminal records across the country. They provide a wide-angle view of an individual’s criminal history.

5. Sex offender registry checks

Specifically, these checks check the national sex offender registry for sexual offences. This helps to ensure that the individuals do not have a record of endangering child welfare or committing sex-related crimes. They’re vital for roles involving vulnerable populations.

types of criminal background checks

6. International criminal record checks

These checks are necessary for individuals who have lived or worked abroad, providing insights into criminal activities committed overseas.

7. Credit background checks

In roles involving financial responsibility, these checks provide insight into an individual’s financial history.

What shows up on a criminal background check?

1. Criminal convictions and records

A criminal background check reveals any past criminal convictions of an individual. This includes felonies, misdemeanors, and other criminal offenses.

In some cases, arrest records may also appear on a criminal background check, providing information about past arrests and charges even if no convictions have occurred.

2. Warrants and outstanding charges

Criminal background checks may reveal outstanding warrants or pending charges against the individual.

In some cases, driving records are also dug through to reveal traffic violations or suspensions of licenses.

3. Employment history and character references

While not directly related to criminal activity, a background check often covers verification of employment history, which can provide insights into an individual’s work experience and character.

It may also involve conducting reference checks to gain a deeper understanding of their market reputation and work profile.

4. Education verification and professional licenses

A background check can verify an individual’s educational credentials, providing accurate and truthful information about their suitability for a given role.

Certain professions similarly require verification of licenses in order to ensure that the individual meets the necessary requirements.

How long do criminal background checks take?

1. The typical time frame for a background check

  • Instant checks: Automated databases can often return results instantly or within a few minutes.
  • Manual searches: Manual searches, such as courthouse record checks, can take several days or even weeks.
  • Multiple jurisdictions: Checks involving multiple jurisdictions or countries can add to the time frame due to varying procedures and response times.

2. Factors influencing the duration of a check

  • Type of check: Different types of checks can take different amounts of time. For example, a county criminal record check may be quicker than a federal or multi-jurisdiction check.
  • Depth of search: The more comprehensive the search, the longer it may take. A check that includes education, employment, and reference verification will take longer than a criminal record check alone.
  • Individual’s criminal history: If the individual has a complex criminal history or has lived in multiple places, the check may take longer.
  • Bureaucratic delays: Delays can also occur due to bureaucratic processes, such as slow response times from courts or other institutions.

3. Differences in the time frame based on check type

  • Credit checks: Credit checks often return results quickly, as they rely on automated databases.
  • Motor vehicle records checks: These checks can also be quick, depending on the state’s procedures.
  • Criminal record checks: These checks can vary widely in duration, depending on the jurisdictions involved and the depth of the search.

4. How the complexity of the applicant’s history affects the duration

  • Lengthy criminal history: More time may be needed to verify and analyze each incident in the applicant’s history.
  • Multiple residences: If the applicant has lived in multiple places, each jurisdiction may need to be checked, adding to the time frame.
  • Common name: If the applicant has a common name, it may take longer to ensure that the records match the correct individual.

How to run a criminal background check successfully?

How to run a criminal background check successfully?

1. Steps involved in conducting a check

  • Obtaining consent: Before starting the check, it’s crucial to obtain the individual’s consent. This is not just a courtesy – it’s a legal requirement.
  • Conducting the check: The check can be conducted using various methods, from online databases to manual courthouse searches. The method depends on the depth and scope of the check. 

The method you choose should align with the depth and scope of the check you need. Remember, the more comprehensive the check, the more thorough the investigation should be.

  • Analyzing the results: After the check, you’ll be left with a wealth of data waiting to be analyzed. You’ll need to verify the information, ensuring it’s accurate and pertains to the right individual. 

2. Dealing with incomplete or inconclusive results 

  • Verifying the information: If the results are incomplete or inconclusive due to various reasons, such as unreported crimes, expunged records, or errors in the data, it may be necessary to verify the information. 

This could involve cross-checking with other sources or requesting additional details.

  • Understanding the limitations: It’s also important to understand the limitations of background checks. 

Not all crimes are reported, and not all reported crimes are recorded in the databases used for background checks.

3. How to interpret the results? 

  • Interpreting the context: It’s not just about identifying any criminal records – it’s about understanding what those records mean in the context of the individual and the situation. 

For example, a minor offense committed many years ago may be less relevant than a recent serious offense.

  • Assessing their relevance: The relevance of the findings to the situation at hand also needs to be assessed. 

For instance, a driving offense may be irrelevant for a desk job but critical for a delivery driver role.

Conducting criminal background checks online

1. Offers speed and convenience

Online background checks offer the advantage of quick results and can be conducted from anywhere with an internet connection. 

They primarily involve searching public records, such as court records, to gather information about an individual’s criminal history.

2. Choose reliable platforms

Choose reputable and trustworthy online platforms such as Checkr, GoodHire, or Sterling that adhere to legal compliance and privacy laws. 

Verify that the online platform maintains strong security measures to protect sensitive personal information and handles data responsibly.

3. Background check procedures

Enter the required details of the individual into the online platform’s search tool accurately to initiate the check. Ensure you have obtained the individual’s consent before conducting an online background check.

Future trends in criminal background checks

1. Technological advances and their impact

Advancements in technology have had a profound impact on the field of criminal background checks. Innovations such as automation, data analytics, and biometrics are shaping how checks are conducted, majorly enhancing their accuracy and efficiency.

2. The role of AI and machine learning

AI and machine learning algorithms are revolutionizing the background check process. 

These technologies can analyze vast amounts of data, identify patterns, and make predictions, streamlining the screening hiring process and providing more precise results.

3. Legal and ethical considerations

As technology evolves, legal and ethical considerations become crucial. Balancing the need for comprehensive background checks with privacy rights and non-discrimination regulations is essential. 

Adhering to relevant laws and maintaining ethical practices is key.

Frequently asked questions

1. Are criminal background checks always necessary for every position?

The necessity of a criminal background check depends on the nature of the position and the level of responsibility involved. Certain roles, such as those in healthcare or finance, may require more rigorous checks than others.

2. Can an individual’s criminal history impact their chances of employment?

Yes, an individual’s criminal history can affect their employment prospects. Employers consider the nature of the offense, its relevance to the job, and whether it poses a risk to the organization or other employees.

3. Can a criminal background check uncover sealed or expunged records?

In most cases, sealed or expunged records should not appear on a criminal background check. There may be exceptions, such as when applying for certain sensitive roles or government positions.

P.S. If you’re looking for an AI-powered ATS + CRM solution, then check out Recruit CRM. Book a demo now to see it in action!